|
|
|
4939 0 0 0 |
|
Опции темы | Поиск в этой теме |
23.06.2011, 14:59 | 1 |
Новичок
Регистрация: 26.06.2010 Последняя активность: 07.03.2011 04:31
Сообщений: 21
Сказал(а) спасибо: 0
Поблагодарили: 2 раз(а) в 2 сообщениях
|
AA Alkaline continuous Discharge Test
This thread is about the finding of which alkaline cells perform best and how each perform under a continuous discharge load.
Update 2010-01-18: Table updated with TESCO branded batteries All cells are purchased off the retail malls/shops. Using Sanyo Eneloop as the base reference. Discharge equipment used is MAHA MH-C9000 WizardOne Charger-Analyzer, manufacturing date code 0I0BA, room temperature 25-28 degree celcius. First, some legend: M - Manufacturing Date E - Expiry Date CHN - China IND - Indonesia JPN - Japan SGP - Singapore USA - USA THL - Thailand !! - MAHA MH-C9000 display DONE immediately upon inserting battery or last discharge current is less than 20mAh List of batteries tested: Duracell Alkaline Sanyo Alkaline Panasonic Alkaline Panasonic Evolta Energizer e2 Advanced Energizer MAX Ikea AA- thanks polkiuj TESCO Batteries - thanks pseudoblue TESCO Value Zinc chloride (ok, this is not alkaline...) TESCO Everyday TESCO Power Hi Tech The discharge function in MAHA MH-C9000 allows to select the discharge rate desired, in this test, we will focus on a discharge current of 500mA and 1000mA on the 1st discharge, while subsequent discharge current at 200mA. MH-C9000 will discharge each cell down to 0.90V and terminate, the word DONE will be display at the LCD. A rest of at least 1 to 2 hours between discharge cycle to allow the cell Voltage to rebound and stabilize. Here is the results: The numbers are what displayed at MH-C9000 LCD after it's done discharging for the cycle. The above result serves only as an alternative to what you may find on the Internet and cpf, it is not to be taken as authoritative reference, I'm NOT in any way a battery expert, but a curious consumer that happens to have an interesting equipment that allows me to do some testing and experimenting. I'm surprised to have found how some cells performs in the least expected manner. As some cells performance are quite unexpected, I'll be doing more testing and update this thread as soon as the testing and data gathering is done. This is the first time I'm doing this, so I greatly appreciate your pointing out any short-comings and mistakes I've made and I will try my best to correct it in future version and testing. TIA. Observations (WIP): - I've recorded the voltage after 30 minutes of discharge, at 0.5A, Eneloop is reading ~1.21V while all alkaline cells tested reads between 1.03-1.18V; at 1.0A discharge, Eneloop is reading ~1.14V while all alkaline cells drop below 1.05V. Note: - As pointed out by Tom (SilverFox): "there are often variations in cell performance with different batches of cells and from cells purchased at different locations", so YMMV. for those who lives in SEA, I have another version with pricing information link here, the default currency is in Ringgit Malaysia |
Поблагодарили: 1 раз |
Sergey@yeisk (25.06.2011)
|